| Reservoir Number Two | Hudson, NJ | 1.4 miles | NE |
| Reservoir Number Three | Hudson, NJ | 1.4 miles | NE |
| Hackensack Reservoir Number Two | Hudson, NJ | 3.4 miles | NE |
| Hackensack Reservoir Number One | Hudson, NJ | 4.3 miles | NE |
| Croton Reservoir (historical) | New York, NY | 5.3 miles | NE |
| Hendricks Pond | Essex, NJ | 6.6 miles | NW |
| Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir | New York, NY | 7.2 miles | NE |
| Silver Lake Reservoir | Richmond, NY | 7.2 miles | SW |
| Yantacaw Pond | Passaic, NJ | 7.6 miles | NW |
| Oakes Pond (historical) | Essex, NJ | 7.7 miles | NW |
| Hughes Lake | Passaic, NJ | 8.9 miles | NW |
| Indian Lake | Bergen, NJ | 9.1 miles | NE |
| Basking Reservoir | Passaic, NJ | 10.4 miles | NW |
| Ridgewood Reservoir | Queens, NY | 10.4 miles | SE |
| Dundee Lake | Passaic, NJ | 11 miles | NW |
| Verona Lake | Essex, NJ | 11.1 miles | NW |
| Orange Reservoir | Essex, NJ | 11.2 miles | NW |
| Cedar Grove Reservoir | Essex, NJ | 11.3 miles | NW |
| Campbells Pond | Essex, NJ | 11.9 miles | NW |
| Great Notch Reservoir | Passaic, NJ | 11.9 miles | NW |
| Diamond Mill Pond | Essex, NJ | 12 miles | NW |
| Zabriskies Pond | Bergen, NJ | 12.8 miles | NE |
| Jacksons Pond | Union, NJ | 12.9 miles | SW |
| New Street Reservoir | Passaic, NJ | 13.2 miles | NW |
| Highland Lake | Passaic, NJ | 13.5 miles | NW |
| Briant Pond | Union, NJ | 13.5 miles | SW |
| Bloodgoods Pond | Union, NJ | 13.5 miles | SW |
| Cope Lake | Bronx, NY | 13.6 miles | NE |
| Taylor Lake | Essex, NJ | 13.6 miles | NW |
| Stanley M Levine Reservoir | Passaic, NJ | 13.7 miles | NW |
| Middlesex Reservoir | Union, NJ | 14.2 miles | SW |
| Jerome Park Reservoir | Bronx, NY | 14.3 miles | NE |
| Milton Lake | Middlesex, NJ | 14.4 miles | SW |
| Canoe Brook Reservoir Number One | Essex, NJ | 14.5 miles | NW |
| Williamsbridge Reservoir | Bronx, NY | 14.7 miles | NE |
| Commonwealth Water Company Reservoir Number Three | Essex, NJ | 15.2 miles | NW |
| Canoe Brook Reservoir Number Two | Essex, NJ | 15.3 miles | NW |
| Shackamaxon Lake | Union, NJ | 15.9 miles | SW |
| Oldham Pond | Passaic, NJ | 16 miles | NW |
| Oradell Reservoir | Bergen, NJ | 16 miles | NE |
| Lake Surprise | Union, NJ | 16.1 miles | SW |
| Van Winkles Pond | Passaic, NJ | 16.8 miles | NW |
| Hillview Reservoir | Westchester, NY | 16.9 miles | NE |
| Packanack Lake | Passaic, NJ | 17 miles | NW |
| Pine Lake | Bergen, NJ | 17.6 miles | NE |
| Seeleys Pond | Union, NJ | 17.6 miles | SW |
| Schlegel Lake | Bergen, NJ | 17.7 miles | NE |
| Udalls Millpond | Nassau, NY | 17.7 miles | NE |
| Barbour Pond | Passaic, NJ | 17.8 miles | NW |
| Duck Pond | Passaic, NJ | 17.9 miles | NE |
|