| Weequahic Lake | Essex, NJ | 2.7 miles | SW |
| Cable Lake | Essex, NJ | 5.3 miles | NW |
| Crystal Lake | Essex, NJ | 6 miles | NW |
| Clarks Pond | Essex, NJ | 6.1 miles | NW |
| Kingsland Lake | Essex, NJ | 6.4 miles | NE |
| Lake Vincent | Essex, NJ | 6.7 miles | NW |
| Butler Pond | Essex, NJ | 8.2 miles | NW |
| Brooks Lake | Richmond, NY | 8.2 miles | SE |
| North Pond | Essex, NJ | 8.3 miles | NW |
| South Pond | Essex, NJ | 8.4 miles | NW |
| Martling Lake | Richmond, NY | 8.4 miles | SE |
| Valley Lake | Richmond, NY | 8.8 miles | SE |
| Clove Lake | Richmond, NY | 8.9 miles | SE |
| Canoe Brook Reservoir Number 1 | Essex, NJ | 9.3 miles | NW |
| Canoe Brook Reservoir Number 2 | Essex, NJ | 9.9 miles | NW |
| Echo Lake | Union, NJ | 9.9 miles | SW |
| Grasmere Lake | Richmond, NY | 10.3 miles | SE |
| Cameron Lake | Richmond, NY | 10.5 miles | SE |
| Ohrback Lake | Richmond, NY | 10.5 miles | SE |
| Stump Pond | Richmond, NY | 10.5 miles | SE |
| Willow Lake | Bergen, NJ | 10.6 miles | NE |
| Dahnerts Lake | Bergen, NJ | 10.6 miles | NE |
| The Pond | New York, NY | 10.6 miles | NE |
| Butchers Pond | Passaic, NJ | 10.9 miles | NW |
| The Lake | New York, NY | 10.9 miles | NE |
| Turtle Pond | New York, NY | 11.1 miles | NE |
| Walker Pond | Richmond, NY | 11.1 miles | SE |
| Barbour Pond | Passaic, NJ | 11.4 miles | NW |
| The Pool | New York, NY | 11.8 miles | NE |
| Prospect Park Lake | Kings, NY | 12.1 miles | SE |
| Harlem Meer | New York, NY | 12.3 miles | NE |
| Roveres Lake | Passaic, NJ | 12.7 miles | NW |
| Swins Ponds | Passaic, NJ | 13.5 miles | NW |
| Adams Lake | Passaic, NJ | 13.8 miles | NW |
| Bridge Pond | Passaic, NJ | 14.1 miles | NW |
| Bee Meadow Pond | Morris, NJ | 14.2 miles | NW |
| Grebe Pond | Passaic, NJ | 14.4 miles | NW |
| Forge Pond | Morris, NJ | 14.5 miles | NW |
| Arbutus Lake | Richmond, NY | 14.7 miles | SW |
| Lotz Pond | Passaic, NJ | 14.8 miles | NW |
| Country Club Ponds | Passaic, NJ | 15.1 miles | NW |
| Wolfes Pond | Richmond, NY | 15.2 miles | SW |
| Cedar Brook Lake | Middlesex, NJ | 15.5 miles | SW |
| Hinchman Pond | Passaic, NJ | 15.5 miles | NW |
| Best Lake | Somerset, NJ | 16 miles | SW |
| Toms Lake | Passaic, NJ | 16 miles | NW |
| Cooper Pond | Bergen, NJ | 16.1 miles | NE |
| Indian Pond | Bronx, NY | 16.2 miles | NE |
| Alexanders Pond | Passaic, NJ | 16.8 miles | NW |
| Robinson Pond (historical) | Middlesex, NJ | 16.9 miles | SW |
|